When something goes horribly wrong in a contract or in the workplace, the first reaction is to try and understand it and maybe put it right. If this isn’t likely to happen then the next reaction might be to look for help. This could be to consider any remedies open to getting results that would put things back to the way they should be or it might be to look for support from friends at a time when things are obviously not going well.
“I need help” is the next of Louise Penny’s “recipe for life” and is also gives further insight into the world of mediation.
By their nature, mediations remain strictly confidential and so there are no records in the public domain of what has gone on. The first implications of this, especially in today’s world, is that there are no recordings and negotiating an agreement to this is not always easy. The second implication is that the session is closed to outsiders and that means that “bringing a friend” is not an option. Whilst in certain types of mediation, lawyers may accompany their clients, even so the mediation is structured so that no one has a particular advantage.
The area of employment disputes or workplace disputes, this can become very difficult. The first reaction if it looks serious might be to consider talking to the union or union rep. Many union reps are well aware of mediation and the ground rules, but not all are, and so before anything happens a lot of time can be spent explaining and negotiating by the mediator, obviously with reference to the party that is concerned. A mediator is neutral, something that is emphasised throughout the process, and cannot be seen to take sides or favour one party above another. In the UK, mediation also allows for solutions to be agreed that may not be based exclusively on the legal position – something which allows for creativity but also an acknowledgement of the wishes of all parties.
Another side of “I need help”, and of more concern, are the appearances of Dr or Judge Google (or AI these days) as an authority source and/or the well-meaning friend. Unless the friend is a lawyer or indeed has deep experience in the area of the dispute, the help offered is often better directed at emotional support or support for other collateral stakeholders who will be affected by the process. The words that nobody wants to hear in a delicate negotiation are “but my friends told me that…” where the full context of that case may be very different and discussions and debates about it can use up valuable time and resources away from the main focus of the mediation.
The time available to mediate a dispute is not elastic or unbounded. Help is important which is why the initial discussions can reveal areas and ideas to consider. But sometimes, “my friend says” is not always as useful as intended.