Louise Penny had four principal tenets for inspector Gamache, her chief protagonist. The next of these is “I don’t know”.

In mediations, a common problem is that each party to the mediation doesn’t know the full story about the other side’s position. Disclosing that in a neutral and supportive environment may bring about significant change and the ability to move on from what can be a very difficult and fraught situation.

The idea of information asymmetry is not new. It’s one of the most important ideas in areas of study that overlap economics, sociology and psychology, such as transaction cost economics. On a practical note, it also informs our daily life. One of the early pieces of research that was done in this area by George Akerlof, featured information asymmetries about used cars or “lemons” to quote from the paper title. We see this all the time in daily life – a good or service may be worth more to one person than to another, or if the market is not transparent, the value may remain unknown. While social media has done much to break down barriers about information asymmetries, in an emotionally charged mediation, behaviours may not be rational and values placed on behaviours or objects may be increased, seeming to be irrational to one side.

We are looking at here is behaviour under stress and the need to be able to exert some sort of control over something, indeed anything. To understand this further, we need to consider another area of research and what is known as the “locus of control”. Under stress, individuals that consider themselves to be powerless, especially in situations where an institution has lined up considerable resources to contest their claims, will seek support from areas where they have got some sort of control. The value to them of certain things becomes exaggerated. In divorces, we might see this in the shape of the desire to retain certain possessions or items. What is happening here is that the desire to control anything, no matter how small, is important to a person’s perceived status and well-being when adrift in an ocean with no control.

The other area of “I don’t know”, that sadly appears all too often, is when parties to a mediation can make claims based on unsound information and when this is challenged, and even possibly shown not to be correct, the emotional temperature in the closed and private mediation can be such that to admit lack of knowledge, or even being wrong, becomes a major issue and can cause a mediation to fail rather than acknowledge and move on.

So information asymmetries and “not knowing” require tranquillity and patience to be gently revealed, discussed calmly and genuine goodwill on all sides to solve the problem and move on. Just like in everyday life!