Reflecting on an apology?
In a workplace dispute, an apology can be surprisingly powerful — but it can also be one of the most difficult things for someone to offer. When relationships have become strained, communication has broken down or a disagreement has been allowed to escalate, saying “I’m sorry” can feel like admitting defeat rather than taking a constructive step towards resolution. Yet for businesses, unresolved conflict can have a much wider impact, affecting individuals, working relationships, team morale and ultimately the organisation itself. Mediation provides a confidential space in which these difficult conversations can take place, helping those involved to understand what has happened and consider what needs to change.
In many mediations, one of the baseline problems is not only about listened to, but also being heard with some action taken about what is being said. Acknowledgment of problems and their historic consequences may require an apology from one side or mutual apologies in order to move forward. But what is a reasonable apology?
An apology isn’t something cursory or, in the words of the TV sitcom character, “Sorry, not sorry”. It should be a considered statement that recognises that there are grounds for hurt feelings and that the behaviour that caused them will change in the future. Contrition should be genuine with an attempt at repairing the damage and the causes.
However, the request for an apology in mediations or workplace disputes is frequently met with a cursory “Sorry, not sorry” style response with a perhaps invisible sigh that this is just a case of having to go through the motions and no desire to change. A little like a bad visit to the dentists – it is something one has to endure, but will soon be over.
All too often, parties in mediations fail to recognise that their own behaviours, both visible and invisible, have contributed to the root cause of the problem. Then when this becomes exposed, they don’t know what to do next without losing face.
The author, Louise Penny, uses four statements that her main protagonist insists his team learn and put into practice:
I am sorry;
I was wrong;
I don’t know;
I need help.
These require an element of humility. If only people felt brave enough to use any or all of these, and follow through, perhaps we might have fewer mediations and easier resolutions. Alas, instead, all too often positions become entrenched, and processes invoked that ultimately make matters worse!
All of us might reflect on these four statements in our daily lives in the hope there would be fewer disagreements. They are not always easy to put into practice, but they can lead to better outcomes.
Perhaps, then, the real value of an apology is not simply in the words themselves, but in what happens afterwards. A meaningful apology can acknowledge what has happened, open the door to rebuilding trust and create the opportunity for a more positive way forward. For employers and individuals facing workplace conflict, mediation can provide the structure and impartial support needed to have those conversations constructively, before positions become even more entrenched. Sometimes, the most productive outcome is not about deciding who was right or wrong, but about understanding what needs to happen next — and having the courage to say, “I am sorry”, “I was wrong”, “I don’t know” or “I need help”.